Geomorphic and Land Use Controls on Sediment Yield in Eastern USA

Abstract

The Reservoir Sedimentation Database (ResSed), a catalogue of reservoirs and depositional data that has recently become publicly available, allows for rapid calculation of sedimentation and capacity-loss rates over short (annual to decadal) timescales. This study is a statistical investigation of factors controlling average sediment yield (Y) in eastern United States watersheds. I develop an ArcGIS-based model that delineates watersheds upstream of ResSed dams and calculate drainage areas to determine Y for 191 eastern US watersheds. Geomorphic, geologic, regional, climatic, and land use variables are quantified within study watersheds using GIS. Sediment yield exhibits a large amount of scatter, ranging from 4.7 to 3336 tonnes1km 2year-1. A weak inverse power law relationship between drainage area (A) and Y (R2 = 0.09) is evident, similar to other studies (e.g., Koppes and Montgomery, 2009). Linear regressions reveal no relationship between mean watershed slope (S) and Y, possibly due to the relatively low relief of the region (mean S for all watersheds is 6°). Analysis of variance shows that watersheds in formerly glaciated regions exhibit a statistically significant lower mean Y (159 tonnes1km-2year-1) than watersheds in unglaciated regions (318 tonnes1km-2year-1), while watersheds with different dam purposes show no significant differences in mean Y. Linear regressions reveal no relationships between land use parameters like percent agricultural, and percent impervious surfaces (I) and Y, but classification and regression trees indicate a threshold in highly developed regions (I > 34%) above which the mean Y (965 tonnes1km-2year-1) is four times higher than watersheds in less developed (I < 34%) regions (237 tonnes1km 2year-1). Further, interactions between land use variables emerge in formerly glaciated regions, where increased agricultural land results in higher rates of annual capacity loss in reservoirs (R2 = 0.56). Plots of Y versus timescale of measurement (e.g., Sadler and Jerolmack, 2014) show that nearly the full range of observed Y, including the highest values, are seen over short survey intervals (< 20 years), suggesting that whether or not large sedimentation events (such as floods) occur between two surveys may explain the high degree of variability in measured rates.